The concept of free will could be little more than the result of background noise in the brain, according to a recent study.
It has previously been suggested that our perceived ability to make autonomous choices is an illusion – and now scientists from the Center for Mind and Brain at the University of California, Davis, have found that free will may actually be the result of electrical activity in the brain.
According to the research, published in the Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience, decisions could be predicted based on the pattern of brain activity immediately before a choice was made.
Volunteers in the study were asked to sit in front of a screen and focus on its central point while their brains’ electrical activity was recorded. They were then asked to make a decision to look either left or right when a cue symbol appeared on the screen, and then to report their decision.
The cue to look left or right appeared at random intervals, so the volunteers could not consciously or unconsciously prepare for it.
The brain has a normal level of so-called background noise; the researchers found that the pattern of activity in the brain in the seconds before the cue symbol appeared – before the volunteers knew they were going to make a choice – could predict the likely outcome of the decision.
snip
“The state of the brain right before presentation of the cue determines whether you will attend to the left or to the right,” Bengson said.
******************************************************************************************************************************************
REALLY??? REALLY???
After reading this ‘scientific’ study, my cognitive assessment of ‘science’ has lost several more points on my common sense scale and it wasn’t all that high to begin with.
This ‘study’ is so ridiculous on its face that it doesn’t even merit a place in any serious catagory, let alone the study of how the mind works. The premise is beyond absurd if their intent was to prove that free will is predictable, when all it REALLY proves is that people are prone to follow instructions…which IS predictable in a LOT of cases.
Let me proffer my own assessment of this study and YOU decide which makes more sense.
Free will is exhibited in the original sense by CHOOSING to participate in this farce. The participants DID volunteer after all for one reason or another. No one shoved them into a line or ordered them to do it. That is an example of free will.
The NEXT decision is whether you CHOOSE to follow the instructions as given. The brain is already working on that decision at that time. What if, upon receiving the instructions, you decide to turn around and walk away because it’s so silly? MY first thought was what if I don’t WANT to look right or left. What if I wait for the cue and blink instead? What if I simply ignore their cue? Will I play their game and THEN do what they don’t expect? What have they proven then?
OF COURSE the brain is actively gearing up in anticipation of doing SOMETHING while waiting for the cue…and that is ALL. What you DECIDE to do is totally UNPREDICTABLE and these ‘scientists’ were counting on the PREDICTABLE , statistically proven response to authority to give them the results they already expected…except that even THAT is wrong.
I would be willing to bet that 100% of the volunteers had already decided, long before the cue, which way they were going to look. Therefore, once again, in anticipation of the cue, the brain goes into gear to send electrical messages to the eyes to move which would ALSO increase electrical brain activity each and every time.
Free will is NOT an illusion. It is real and active in every facet of our existence. Things that influence our decisions vary from day to day and minute to minute, sometimes from nanosecond to nanosecond. The brain is a supercomputer capable of processing information at speeds rocket scientists should envy.
Free will is a woman facing death in Sudan for refusing to renounce her faith in the face of certain death.
Free will is choosing to murder or choosing the opposite.
Free will is a soldier throwing himself on a grenade to save the lives of his Brothers in Arms.
Free will is choosing to murder an unborn child out of either selfishness or convenience.
Free will is choosing to have that child regardless of the circumstances.
Free will is choosing to get up in the morning and go to work or call in sick.
Free will is choosing to replace your lost legs and learning to walk or staying in a wheelchair as a victim eliciting self-serving pity for the rest of your life.
So what was learned exactly in this ‘scientific study’? I’ll tell you what.
ABSOLUTELY NOTHING. It HAS proven the old adage that there is a sucker born every minute…and that much of the ‘scientific community’ exploits that adage every whichaway but loose.